Afterpay vs humm: Which is a better service for me?

Afterpay vs humm: Which is a better service for me? | RateCity

Buy now, pay later (BNPL) is a way for you to purchase goods and pay for them later in smaller, manageable instalments spread over a few weeks or months. Most BNPL service providers don't charge any interest on the repayments, which makes them a popular alternative to credit cards. Instead, they charge late fees and/or account keeping fees, which means you typically end up paying nothing (or almost nothing) for using the service if you make your repayments on time.

The wildly popular BNPL service, Afterpay, which is also the first BNPL service in Australia, added an average of 17,300 new customers to the platform daily in the financial year 2020. Following its success, many new players entered the market with pretty much the same model of allowing customers to buy what they want and delay paying for it without charging any interest to them. Where these services usually differ is in how much you can spend, how you repay the amount borrowed and the charges (or late fees) involved. 

For instance, you can spend up to a maximum limit of $1,500 with Afterpay. A smaller spending limit on Afterpay is suitable for everyday spending, but you can't use it to break down a larger expense, such as the cost of a dental treatment. If you are searching for an alternative to Afterpay with a higher spending limit, humm could be a service worth considering, with a spending limit of up to $30,000 for planning bigger purchases.

Disclaimer

This article is over two years old, last updated on June 4, 2022. While RateCity makes best efforts to update every important article regularly, the information in this piece may not be as relevant as it once was. Alternatively, please consider checking recent bnpl articles.

Afterpay vs humm: What is the difference?

Both Afterpay and humm are popular BNPL services with a growing user base. The service model is similar, but the right service for you will depend on your individual needs as the features available on both are different.

Here's a list of some important differences between Afterpay and humm you should know about:

  • Spending limits and repayments

    Afterpay allows you to shop now and pay later up to a maximum limit of $1,500. When buying with Afterpay, you need to pay 25 per cent of the amount at the time of purchase. The remainder is payable in three equal instalments that fall due every two weeks. If you wish to pay back your purchase sooner, you can always make a payment before the due date, and you won't be charged any penalty or fees for paying early.

    Like Afterpay, humm allows you to divide the cost of your everyday purchases up to a maximum limit of $2,000 into smaller instalments (or 'slices') using its 'Little things' wallet. You can repay 'Little things' in five fortnightly or 10 weekly slices.

    Additionally, humm offers a 'Big things' wallet to cover payments for an extensive range of products and services up to a maximum of $30,000. You can repay any 'Big things' purchased with humm over six, 12, 24 or even 60 months, without paying any interest. You can make additional payments on any active purchase during the repayment term without penalty or extra fees.

    Interestingly, humm gives you the flexibility to choose the day that you prefer to make your repayments. With Afterpay, if you buy something today, your next payment will be scheduled in two weeks from that day. However, humm gives you the option to match up your regular purchase payment day with your pay day to make it easier to budget for your repayments. It's also possible to change an individual upcoming payment date on humm.

  • Fees and costs

    Afterpay doesn't charge you any monthly fees for using the service. Your repayments are interest-free, but you could be hit by a $10 late payment fee if you miss an instalment. If the payment continues to remain pending for another week, you'll need to shell out a further $7 as additional fees.

    However, Afterpay has some caps in place to prevent consumers from running into debt. For smaller orders under $40, Afterpay promises not to charge you more than $10 in late fees. For orders over $40 and up to $272, the late fee is capped at 25 per cent of the purchase price. And, if you paid more than $272 for an order, the maximum late fee you can be charged by Afterpay is $68.

    Like Afterpay, Humm doesn't charge you any monthly fees for using the 'Little things' wallet if you pay off your purchases in 10 weeks or five fortnights. If you need longer to pay back for the 'Little things' you purchased with humm, you can spread out your repayments over 10 fortnights, but you'll have to pay a monthly fee of $8 for using this feature.

    Similar to Afterpay, humm charges no interest on repayments, but late payment fees apply. For purchases less than $65, the late fee is capped at $6 (lower than Afterpay's $10 cap). For the 'Little things' you buy above this amount, late fees are capped at 18% of the purchase or up to $48, whichever is lower. Late fees on 'Big things' purchases are capped at 18% of the purchase price or up to $78, whichever is lower.

    Using humm's 'Big things' wallet to plan big-ticket expenses attracts several other costs, even though the repayments remain interest-free. For instance, a monthly fee of $8 applies to all the 'Big things' purchased via humm. You also pay an establishment fee of between $35-90 for larger purchases, depending on the price of the item you buy. For all subsequent 'Big things' purchases on humm, you pay a repeat purchase fee of $22 instead of the establishment fee.

    As you can see, the fee structure for humm is a little complicated, especially when you use it for purchasing 'Big things'. To understand the real cost of using the service, there's a handy calculator on the site that lays down all the fees and expenses for you, explaining your options clearly.

  • The number of open orders you can have at a time

    With Afterpay, you'll need approval from the platform before every purchase. When you open an account on Afterpay, you'll most likely only be allowed to have one order approved in the first 24 hours. However, you may be allowed to have multiple open orders simultaneously (but up to your approved credit limit) after a few months of using Afterpay regularly and responsibly by making all your repayments in time. Furthermore, if you miss a repayment on an open purchase, Afterpay will not let you make another purchase until all your payments are up to date.

    Unlike Afterpay, you don't need approval for making multiple purchases using your 'Little things' wallet on humm. The service allows you to buy as many items you like but within your spending limit.

    The 'Big things' wallet on humm works like Afterpay in the sense that you need to get approved by humm before making any purchase. You can get approved online for purchases up to $5,000, but you may need to complete the application process in-store for orders above this price. Note that there's a repeat fee of $22 for every subsequent payment you make using humm's 'Big things'.

Afterpay vs Humm: Which is better?

Both Afterpay and humm are popular buy now, pay later options that let you buy what you need and pay for it later in smaller, interest-free instalments. Afterpay is also Australia's first BNPL service provider and enjoys a relatively larger user base owing to its first-mover advantage. It is also relatively simple to use compared to humm, which provides you with several payment plans and multiple fee structures that could confuse some users. At the same time, humm allows you the flexibility of playing around with your repayment schedule to an extent and offers an additional service to pay for large purchases up to $30,000, which is missing in Afterpay.

While the right service for you depends on your personal choice and requirement, one could broadly say that Afterpay is suitable for consumer shopping while humm could be helpful to plan your big-ticket purchases. 

Irrespective of the service you choose, it's worth remembering that BNPL is a form of credit eventually. Therefore, it's important to use it responsibly to avoid landing in a pile of debt. It's good to calculate your repayments for a product or service you wish to buy using BNPL and run this number by your budget to confirm whether you can afford to pay for it. However, if you have had trouble managing credit in the past or find it challenging to spend on a budget, it may be better to stick to your savings to purchase what you need.

Questions you may have

What are the alternatives to humm I could consider?

Afterpay and Zip Pay are the leading BNPL providers in Australia. However, they only allow smaller transaction amounts, comparable to the 'Little things' wallet on your humm account. 

If you are looking for help with a bigger expense, Brighte is one BNPL platform that may allow you to borrow a maximum of $30,000 for up to 60 months. However, Brighte generally only offers interest-free payment plans for making energy-efficient upgrades to your home, such as solar and batteries, or other home improvement projects. 

Do BNPL service providers charge late payment fees?

BNPL service providers will invariably charge you late fees if you miss your repayments, which can range from $5-$15 each time the payment is delayed. Late payment fees are also usually capped at either a set dollar figure or as centage of the outstanding balance.

Can I sign up on multiple BNPL platforms?

You can sign up for multiple BNPL services, but consider using just one platform as you will be accumulating multiple debts otherwise, which can be difficult to keep track of. You also risk having to pay more fees to more providers.

ratecity-newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter

Product database updated 23 Nov, 2024
Fact Checked

This article was reviewed by Personal Finance Editor Alex Ritchie before it was published as part of RateCity's Fact Check process.

RateCity